Introduction

“Solving Product Design Exercises” by Artiom Dashinsky is a practical guide aimed at helping product designers, UX professionals, and aspiring tech industry candidates navigate the challenging landscape of product design interviews. Dashinsky, drawing from his extensive experience in the field, offers a structured approach to tackling design challenges commonly encountered during job interviews at top tech companies. The book’s primary purpose is to equip readers with the tools, methodologies, and mindset necessary to excel in product design interviews and, by extension, in their professional careers.

Summary of Key Points

Understanding the Interview Process

  • Interview structure: Dashinsky outlines the typical format of product design interviews, which often include portfolio reviews, whiteboard challenges, and behavioral questions.
  • Interviewer expectations: The author emphasizes that interviewers are looking for candidates who can demonstrate problem-solving skills, creativity, and the ability to articulate their design process.
  • Common pitfalls: The book highlights frequent mistakes candidates make, such as focusing too much on visual design and not enough on problem-solving.

The Product Design Framework

  • Five-step approach: Dashinsky introduces a comprehensive framework for solving design exercises:
    1. Understand the problem
    2. Define the goals
    3. Sketch ideas
    4. Explain the solution
    5. Identify next steps
  • Adaptability: The framework is designed to be flexible and applicable to a wide range of design challenges.
  • Time management: Tips are provided on how to allocate time effectively within the constraints of an interview setting.

Problem Understanding and Goal Setting

  • User-centric approach: The book emphasizes the importance of identifying the target users and their needs before diving into solutions.
  • Asking the right questions: Dashinsky provides a list of essential questions to ask to fully grasp the problem space.
  • SMART goals: The author advocates for setting Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound goals for each design challenge.

Ideation and Sketching Techniques

  • Quantity over quality: The book encourages generating numerous ideas quickly rather than fixating on perfecting a single concept.
  • Sketching tools: Various sketching techniques are discussed, from simple wireframes to more detailed mockups.
  • Divergent thinking: Dashinsky provides exercises to help readers expand their creative thinking and generate diverse solutions.

Presenting and Explaining Solutions

  • Storytelling: The importance of crafting a compelling narrative around the design solution is highlighted.
  • Visual aids: Tips on creating clear, concise visual representations of ideas are provided.
  • Handling feedback: Strategies for receiving and responding to interviewer feedback constructively are discussed.

Beyond the Interview

  • Portfolio development: Advice on creating a strong portfolio that showcases problem-solving skills is offered.
  • Continuous learning: The book emphasizes the importance of staying updated with industry trends and continuously improving one’s skills.
  • Career growth: Dashinsky provides insights on navigating career paths in product design and UX.

Key Takeaways

  • Product design interviews are as much about demonstrating problem-solving skills as they are about showcasing visual design abilities.
  • A structured approach to design challenges, such as Dashinsky’s five-step framework, can significantly improve performance in interviews and real-world projects.
  • Understanding user needs and business goals is crucial before jumping into solution mode.
  • Rapid ideation and sketching are valuable skills that can be developed through practice.
  • The ability to articulate design decisions and tell a compelling story about the design process is often as important as the solution itself.
  • Time management is critical in interview settings; practicing with time constraints can improve performance.
  • Feedback should be viewed as an opportunity for growth rather than criticism.
  • A strong portfolio should demonstrate problem-solving skills and the ability to handle complex design challenges.
  • The product design field requires continuous learning and adaptation to new technologies and user needs.
  • Soft skills, such as communication and collaboration, are essential complements to technical design skills.

Critical Analysis

Strengths

  • Practical approach: Dashinsky’s book stands out for its highly practical, hands-on approach to product design challenges. The exercises and examples provided are directly applicable to real-world interview scenarios.
  • Comprehensive framework: The five-step framework presented in the book offers a clear, structured approach that can be particularly beneficial for less experienced designers or those new to tech industry interviews.
  • Industry insights: Drawing from his experience, Dashinsky provides valuable insider knowledge about what top tech companies look for in candidates, giving readers a competitive edge.
  • Emphasis on problem-solving: By focusing on the thought process behind design decisions rather than just visual outcomes, the book aligns well with current industry expectations.
  • Adaptability: The principles and techniques discussed are not limited to interviews but can be applied to everyday product design challenges, making the book valuable beyond job-seeking contexts.

Weaknesses

  • Potential oversimplification: While the structured approach is helpful, some critics might argue that it could lead to formulaic responses in interviews, potentially stifling creativity.
  • Limited focus on visual design: While the book’s emphasis on problem-solving is a strength, some readers might find the coverage of visual design principles and trends insufficient.
  • Rapid evolution of the field: Given the fast-paced nature of the tech industry, some specific tools or techniques mentioned in the book may become outdated quickly.
  • Cultural specificity: The book’s advice may be most applicable to North American and European tech companies, potentially limiting its global relevance.

Contribution to the Field

“Solving Product Design Exercises” makes a significant contribution to the field of product design education and career development. It bridges the gap between academic design education and the practical skills required in industry interviews and professional settings. By demystifying the interview process and providing a clear methodology for approaching design challenges, Dashinsky’s work empowers designers to present their skills more effectively.

The book has sparked discussions within the design community about the nature of design interviews and whether current practices effectively evaluate a candidate’s potential. Some argue that the focus on rapid problem-solving in artificial scenarios may not fully capture a designer’s abilities, while others appreciate the book for preparing candidates for the realities of the interview process.

Controversies and Debates

  • Standardization vs. creativity: Some designers argue that frameworks like Dashinsky’s might lead to a standardization of design thinking, potentially stifling unique approaches.
  • Interview format critique: The book has contributed to ongoing debates about the effectiveness of whiteboard challenges and time-constrained exercises in assessing design talent.
  • Diversity and inclusion: While not directly addressed in the book, its publication has prompted discussions about how standardized interview processes might impact diversity in the tech industry.
  • Ethical considerations: Some readers have called for more emphasis on ethical design practices and consideration of potential negative impacts of products during the design process.

Conclusion

Artiom Dashinsky’s “Solving Product Design Exercises” is a valuable resource for product designers at various stages of their careers, particularly those preparing for job interviews in the tech industry. The book’s strengths lie in its practical, structured approach to design challenges and its insider insights into the interview process at top tech companies.

While it may not cover every aspect of product design in depth, its focus on problem-solving methodology and communication of design decisions addresses a critical need in the industry. The book not only prepares readers for interviews but also enhances their overall approach to product design challenges.

For aspiring and practicing product designers, UX professionals, and even those in adjacent fields looking to transition into product design, this book offers a concrete set of tools and strategies to improve their skills and career prospects. However, readers should complement this resource with other materials that delve deeper into visual design principles, ethical considerations, and the latest industry trends.

In the rapidly evolving field of product design, Dashinsky’s work serves as a solid foundation upon which professionals can build their careers, encouraging a thoughtful, user-centric approach to solving design problems. Whether used as interview preparation or as a guide for approaching real-world design challenges, “Solving Product Design Exercises” is likely to remain a relevant and useful tool for designers seeking to excel in their field.

If you’re interested in purchasing “Solving Product Design Exercises” by Artiom Dashinsky, you can find it on Amazon. By using this link, you’ll be supporting our work as we earn a small commission from your purchase. Thank you for your support!